Find a reputable business?

Reputation Report

First Premier Home Warranty

  462 inquiries |
Homeowner Insurance and Warranty Services

2918 Avenue R
Brooklyn, NY 11229
| Get Directions

(800) 388-1918

http://www.firstpremierhomewar...

Company Rating

F

View Rating Explanation

Customer Reviews

based on 6 reviews.

Write Review

View Customer Reviews

Complaint Experience

39%

Complaint Resolution Index (CRI)

18 complaints closed in last 3 years.

View Complaints

Membership Information

This business is not a member of Business Consumer Alliance. This fact does not disparage the company in any way.

Recent Review

Posted on 1/8/2026

They need to take a class in Customer Service

I'm complaining about the 12 months of service +3 months of double billing and trying to get out of a month to month contract. You have to pay them $75 plus you still have to pay them your plan which is mine for $46. they are very rude nasty inconsiderate and they talk to you like they better than you. They try to make it seem that you're the one stupid you call them they give you a policy number. That is not good. Every time I call them with my policy number one representative can get it with my policy number for another representative. Can't find it with my policy number. The policy don't exist. but like I told my last representative that I talk to that was a pleasure talking to. She asked me or their way that I will stay with their company. I told her no I said, even if your company can walk waters, I will not sign another contract with them and I will not recommend them to any of my friends family anybody I know they're comfortable will not come out of my mouth unless someone is trying to sign a contract would've asked me about them. They don't even have to ask me about them. They talking about them they don't even bother. They have a problem. They are a rip off. They get you to sign with them and then they treat you like trash. they don't even need to be in business with the representative that they have. They are the first person that a new customer will have to talk to. I have been with T-Mobile over 20 years and they have good customer service.

Read More

View All Reviews

Complaints and Resolutions

Total Amount in Dispute:
$10,263.00

Total Amount Settled:
$0.00

Complaint Experience

39%

Complaint Resolution Index (CRI)

BCA's Summary and Analysis:

Our complaint history for this company shows the company gave proper consideration to some complaints presented to them.

Although in some cases the company failed to respond to complaints.

Read More

Our complaint services are free and our team of expert mediators will assist in resolving complaints with businesses.

File Complaint

Complaint Closing Statistics

18 complaints against First Premier Home Warranty closed in last 3 years.
Complaints Type of response
0 Making a full refund, as the consumer requested
0 Making a partial refund
3 Agreed to make an adjustment
0 Refusing to make an adjustment
4 Refuse to adjust, relying on terms of agreement
11 Unanswered

View summaries of the complaint descriptions and responses.

View Complaints

Other Information

Company Info

This company's business offers homeowner insurance and warranty services.

Primary Contact: Joseph Demarco (Claims Manager)
Business Started: N/A
Social:

Interested in First Premier Home Warranty?
Contact them directly!

Request Quote

Licensing

We know of no licensing or registration requirement for companies engaged in this company's stated type of business.

Read More

Government Actions

BCA has no information regarding government actions at this time.

Comments and Analysis

We have no further comment about this company's business practices or analysis of its offer that may assist you in your consideration of this company.

Other Considerations

We know of no other matter or practice relating to this company that may assist you in your consideration of this company.

Industry Resources
Advertising Reviews
Additional Info

DBAs:
There are no additional DBAs.

Websites:
There are no additional web sites.

Contacts:

Customer Service
Jordan Weiss (Claims Department)
Joe Mitchel (Senior Account Executive )
Vince Walker (President)